Who did it better? Beyoncé or Mariah Carey?

Topless concept. Check. Trench coat. Check. Tiny black bottoms. Check. Last week, Beyoncé debuted a brand new photoshoot for CR Fashion Book and one of the pics showed her topless rocking a trench coat. 

Of course this shoot went without notice by sharp eyed Mariah lambs, who were quick to point out that Mariah did a very similar shoot in 1997. Who did it better in your eyes? Beyoncé or Mariah?